Commutation Construct
Politics • News • Writing
An open platform for the devils advocates of the world seeking debate and discussion on all forms of sociopolitical and economic inquiry. We host podcasts, videos, and articles on all matters of political philosophy to foster discussion to push our country closer to living up to its ideals.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

Armchair Philosophy, July 11th, 2020

Topic: Fact is Fact, but Perception is All That Matters When Determining Truth

I had an interaction today that left me utterly riled to my core. I was repulsed by what someone said to me about myself. Not because it was a truth that hurt, but because he claimed something of me that violated my principles to their very core. I was told that I do not listen to others to learn, and that I simply await my opportunity to speak. Of course, considering the founding purpose and pursuit of this website, you may be able to understand why I would consider this both a ridiculous and slanderous claim against me. Yet, once I had calmed down, I gave it some thought. Why would a friend make such a claim about me? I reflected back to what I had read about different personality types, as well as my own actions and words, and I realized I can completely understand how someone could get that impression of me, and why the third party in the dialogue would immediately agree with him.

My friends, largely, do not know about this website. They do not know about commutationconstruct.com. They do not know about the time I spend with my community and others discussing and debating ideas, philosophies, and educating myself as to the beliefs and positions of others. Throughout my MBA program I had probably spent more time studying civic and philosophical matters than I had spent on my program itself, as though it were my full time job. I even had jobs where I would listen to podcasts on such topics for entire work days before going to school and then continuing my studies more when I was home from class. It was a personal pursuit that I would hardly even reference in situations where debate would spur among friends and relatives. This left my friends feeling that I was strongly opinionated and not willing to listen because I had already heard their arguments prior and had a solidified response, be it in agreement or disagreement. But because of their imperfect information about me, their perceptions were locked in place.

I also had to consider why I had such a strong emotional reaction to what they said. This had to do with my own perception. I have a personality where I tend to play my cards close to the chest. I don't open up to many people about what I do, I will hide when things hurt me, and I will celebrate momentous events on my own. At the same time, I'm incredibly analytical and will break down every specific use of language by the people around me and consider that in my response or use it as a marker to determine the perception of the people I am with. I naturally pick up on the perception of others fairly well, though I tend to end up in 50/50 scenarios unable to determine which of the viable paths I see as being the correct one. For me, this leaves many possibilities for the perception of others open, and I consider almost nothing in absolutes, so, from my perspective, it is difficult to imagine anyone close to me not being able to recognize the same series of possibilities in me when I speak with them.

I took offense because I had an expectation that they would consider my perspective in the same way I would consider theirs, and they didn't. I also gave them no real reason to question my understanding as coming from anywhere more than a remedial level of experience. This got me thinking about perspective, and what it means for society. I've heard Jonathan Haidt discuss how people with different political opinions can watch the same movie and both would give completely different summaries of what happened if asked about the movie. With media and politics growing increasingly partisan, I believe societal scale perceptions about reality are going through massive shifts.

Primarily, the left and right are losing the ability to communicate. Perception for both sides have labelled the other as unabashedly inept, hateful, and wanting to destroy the security of the other side. The right fears cancel culture, the left fears Trump becoming a dictator and removing all of their rights. Both sides see the other as racist, the left seeing the right as hate filled white supremacists, and the right seeing the left as racists of low expectations and an almost self-hating form of white supremacy. The ineptitude of our leaders may be the one thing agreed upon by both sides, yet both sides also likely embrace the primary leaders from their side, whom the other hates the most, as the devil that is on their side and the only figure currently giving them a fighting chance (see Pelosi & McConnell).

That is roughly where I currently see politics standing, and those views persist on both sides regardless of whatever facts may be brought to the defense of the other. Looking at social order, many digital and social media sites block content they do not approve of. Twitter banning people who say a man is not a woman, or YouTube blocking all Covid information that isn't WHO approved or from a major news outlet are both things that affect how people see the world. If the only world kids grow up in is one where the very questioning of what a transperson is is considered bigoted and hateful, then that is all that the generation will know. That will be the truth to them. This is what propaganda does. It creates a perception, and when that perception reaches a societal level, it might as well be truth, because it will be treated as truth. The manipulation of a cult of ideas.

Ben Shapiro is known for his quote "Facts don't care about your feelings". That is accurate. However, truth, as defined in society and treated throughout culture, does care about perception. Many history books carry false information due to school boards getting to decide what material they will teach and allow to be taught in their schools. Historians simply receive checks for letting the publishers of said books put their names on them. This gives validity to the content within, while allowing the content to reflect only the desired perspective of our leaders in education.

In the end, the main point of this discussion, for me, is that we must care about the perception of those around us and those who we interact with. It is incredibly dangerous for society to have such divisive perspectives that disallow the dialogue between the two primary perspectives of said society, as all alternatives to ones own are seen as evil. Therefore, it is our responsibility, as open minds seeking the betterment of our society, that we work together to consider the perspective of our counterparts so that we may communicate with them, and break through this division.

Alright everyone, this has been a long one from me and I am very curious what you all think. Do you think perception matters more than facts when dealing with other people, or do facts not caring about feelings give us the high ground in confrontation with others? What suggestions do you have for dealing with divided perceptions, or do you believe that my suggestion in this article is complete hogwash? I look forward to any and all responses. Thank you for taking the time to join the discussion today.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
September 14, 2021
Apparently paraphrasing is illegal on YouTube

Just thought I'd share this comment I was trying to comment on a Lotus Eaters video. Btw, ya'll should follow the Podcast of the Lotus Eaters if you aren't already. Great analysis and discussion

00:00:06
Creating Positive Change

It's been a while since I've made a video, and this time with a locals exclusive. A cherry on top that I managed to fit within the size requirements. I like making shorter form content like this, considering my tendencies to ramble. Having content exclusive for my followers here is something I'll be working on doing more and more. I'll be creating more value here for my subscribers as well, with some subscriber exclusive content in the future. No timeline promises, cause I think we know how I get when I make a ton of promises (go hardcore for a week and then fall flat on my face unable to keep up with the sprint, lol).

Anyhow, let me know your thoughts and questions below. Have a great day everyone!

00:09:18
Businesses Are Weird Legal Entities

A direct upload! It turns out I recorded a video just short enough to meet the minimum upload offerings that locals offers to small communities like mine. That means you guys get this exclusively on locals!

I didn't sleep much last night, so I decided this was the perfect time to mull over my confused thoughts on how businesses are viewed from a legal perspective. Businesses are somewhat legal enigmas to me. Corporations are kinda treated as persons so that they can be double taxed, but have other protections, other types of businesses aren't treated the same way. They're able to consolidate power like governments, yet aren't subject to any form of limitations in regards to violating natural rights the same way the government is, despite being treated somewhat like persons they can still buy each other. It's just very odd to me from a principled, legal, and philosophical position.

Anyhow, my ramblings here are just that, ramblings. Still, I am curious what you all think of this topic. ...

00:09:22
Construct Cast Ep. 11: Reflections on Election and Empire

The 2020 election is over, and the battle has just begun. What do I expect to come from the end of the election? Will the legal suits turn over anything for this election, or will they mean something for later down the line? I reflect on these questions and more in this discussion, and I also reflect on some final thoughts relevant to the Rise and Fall of Empire Series, that, thus far, being episodes 8 through 10 of the Construct Cast. Let me know your thoughts, and if you have any reflections of your own from this year's political cycle or other developments that you can't seem to get off your mind in the comments below.

Construct Cast Ep. 11: Reflections on Election and Empire
Construct Cast Ep. 10: Ideas for the Survival of an Empire

In this episode of the Construct Cast, I discuss my analysis of Sir John Glubb's The Fate of Empires and Search for Survival, with an emphasis on my own consideration for what it would take to help an empire survive, or reboot. If immortality for an Empire is impossible, is rebirth impossible in the same way? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.

Editor's Note: Returning to the podcast versions of the Construct Cast, I want to catch our content up to the videos we have had released over the past month. I apologize for this getting away from me for a bit. With the rise in content production, I had allowed this to get away from me. We will be returning to audio podcast uploads of the Construct Cast as per our original regular schedule, at 12PM EST on the day of the original upload, going forward.

Construct Cast Ep. 10: Ideas for the Survival of an Empire
Commutation Crossover 2: Traditionalism vs Conservatism

In this second Crossover podcast, we are once again recording with Kevin @Eng_Politics. His channel is a bastion of political thought and analysis from the perspective of a conservative engineer. Interested in diving deeper into my concept of Progressive Traditionalism and combating the concept with his own beliefs of what it means to be Conservative, we decided to put our definitions and beliefs to task in this crossover episode!

Be sure to check out Kevin's locals community here:
https://engineeringpolitics.locals.com/

And if you're more interested in the video version, here is a direct link:
https://engineeringpolitics.locals.com/post/235260/the-engineering-politics-podcast-30-conservatism-vs-progressive-traditionalism

Commutation Crossover 2: Traditionalism vs Conservatism
Slightly Gross but positive note for those with any IBS related disease

So I just confirmed that, after a year off of the Keto diet, my Ulcerative Colitis (a type of IBS) is still not only in remission, but seemingly cured as if it never was there, including no more polyp growth.

This self-experiment has shown me that a prolonged period on Keto, about 2 years for me, was enough to create the long lasting effects to repair and cure my gastrointestinal system to complete recovery from what was supposed to be a lifelong, incurable illness. I still have a minor level proctitus at the exit, to put it in the least gross way I can think, but with the rest actually fully cured to where my new GI doctor asked if I was misdiagnosed originally is a major accomplishment.

For those seeking a source on how to get here like I did, I recommend following Thomas Delaur's YouTube channel for general inflammation control/healthy keto/ workout advice, only eat meat that is 100% Grass fed and pasture raised (including eggs), and drink a glass of Kefir at least once a week. Good ...

September 08, 2022
Equity Socialism (Not the social kind)

Controversial capitalist take, but I personally don't think stock ownership should give any power to the stockholders over business decisions. Buyouts and ownership should be separate from stock investment. How? There are various options to discuss. Why? Theoretically an investment firm could invest ownership stakes into every major investment firm over time and concentrate all of their investments to own controlling stakes across entire industries or even all publicly traded companies.

Actually, this isn't so theoretical if you look at BlackRock's partnerships with Vanguard and State Street. The three companies operate in virtual lockstep and theoretically wouldn't even need 51% collective ownership in the companies they invest in because any company with an array of other investors should have some theoretical minimum that they can guarantee will follow the leadership of these big 3 in most cases. I've seen estimates that they only need a collective 35% share to all but guarantee any ...

Locals Survey

Want to put this question out there for everyone. How are you all feeling about locals? Do you still regularly use it? Has the fad died? Does it feel too much like an echo chamber to you?

See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals